Are you wondering whether to choose DoorDash or Instacart for your delivery needs? You're not alone. As delivery apps grow in popularity, picking the right one can save you time, money, and hassle. According to Statista, as of May 2025, the revenue in the U.S. online food delivery market is projected to reach $430.85 billion in 2025, showing how important these services have become. 

‍

Additionally, the U.S. grocery delivery market is set to hit $327.72 billion in 2025, making it clear that both meal and grocery delivery are booming.

‍

When it comes to DoorDash vs Instacart, each offers unique benefits depending on your needs. DoorDash is great for hot, ready-to-eat meals, while Instacart is perfect for fresh groceries and household essentials.

‍

Choosing between Instacart vs DoorDash depends on what matters most to you. In this guide, you'll learn their key differences, pros, and cons to help you make the best choice.

‍

DoorDash Overview

DoorDash is a popular delivery platform that connects you with local restaurants, grocery stores, and convenience shops. Launched in 2013, it has grown to serve cities across the United States and beyond. Whether you're craving a burger or need last-minute snacks, DoorDash brings it right to your door.

‍

Key Features and Services

DoorDash offers a variety of services to make everyday ordering convenient, these include:

• Restaurant Delivery: Order meals from thousands of local and national restaurants.
• Grocery and Essentials: Shop for groceries or grab household items from nearby stores.
• DashPass Subscription: Get free delivery and reduced service fees on eligible orders.
• Exclusive Deals: Access discounts and special offers through brand partnerships.
• Fast Delivery Options: Enjoy quick service with optimized delivery times.

In short, DoorDash makes it easy to enjoy meals and more without stepping outside. If food is your main focus, it's a solid choice.

‍

But what if your priority is stocking up on groceries instead of ready-made meals? Let's look at how Instacart can meet that need.

‍

Instacart Overview

Instacart is a leading grocery delivery and pickup service that connects you with local supermarkets. Founded in 2012, it has become a go-to solution for getting groceries, household essentials, and even personal care items delivered to your doorstep.

‍

Key Features and Services

Instacart offers flexible grocery shopping and delivery with these standout features. Some of its key highlights include:

• Wide Store Selection: Shop from multiple local and national grocery stores in your area.
• Same-Day Delivery or Pickup: Choose between fast delivery or a scheduled curbside pickup.
• Instacart+ Membership: Formerly Instacart Express, this subscription includes free delivery on eligible orders and reduced service fees.
• Personal Shoppers: Trained shoppers handpick your items with care and attention to quality.
• Real-Time Updates: Get notified when items are out of stock and approve replacements on the go.

If your main goal is saving time on grocery runs without sacrificing choice, Instacart is a strong option.

‍

Of course, when choosing between these two, it's not just about services; it's about what fits your needs better. Let's discuss the key differences between DoorDash and Instacart to help you decide.

‍

DoorDash vs Instacart: Key Differences

In the debate of DoorDash vs Instacart, it's essential to compare their services to see which one stands out based on your needs. While both platforms offer delivery, their focus and features vary greatly. Here is a comparison to help you understand how they stack up against each other:

‍

With both platforms offering varying features and pricing structures, it's clear that DoorDash vs Instacart will depend on what you're looking for, restaurant meals or groceries.

However, choosing the right service also depends on their strengths. Let's take a closer look at DoorDash's Pros and Cons to help you decide if it's the right fit for your needs.

‍

Pros and Cons of DoorDash

When deciding between DoorDash vs Instacart, understanding the benefits and drawbacks of each platform is crucial. Let's discuss the pros and cons of DoorDash so that you can make a well-informed choice.

‍

Advantages of DoorDash

Here are a few advantages of DoorDash:

• Wide Selection of Restaurants: DoorDash offers a vast array of food options, from local eateries to fast food chains. This extensive variety makes it ideal for satisfying different cravings.
• Fast Delivery: With a large network of drivers, DoorDash often delivers orders in under an hour, making it one of the fastest delivery platforms available.
• Subscription Benefits (DashPass): DashPass offers subscribers free delivery on eligible orders, helping customers save on delivery fees and ensuring a seamless ordering experience.
• Flexible Delivery Options: Customers can choose from delivery, pick-up, or even curbside pick-up at some locations, providing multiple options for convenience.
• Promotions and Discounts: DoorDash frequently offers discounts, promo codes, and special deals to both new and existing users, making it a budget-friendly choice.

‍

Drawbacks of DoorDash

Doordash also has some drawbacks, these include:

• High Delivery Fees: Delivery fees can add up, especially during peak times, and they are often higher than other platforms, which can affect your overall cost.
• Service Fees: In addition to delivery fees, DoorDash charges service fees, which vary depending on the order size and distance, making it an expensive option for larger orders.
• Limited Availability in Rural Areas: While DoorDash is widely available, its service may not reach more remote or rural locations, limiting its convenience for some customers.
• Variable Food Quality: Because DoorDash relies on third-party drivers, food may arrive cold or slightly damaged, depending on the distance and delivery conditions.
• Surge Pricing: Similar to other platforms, DoorDash implements surge pricing during peak hours, making the overall cost higher when demand is high.

While DoorDash offers many benefits, such as fast delivery and a wide variety of options, there are some drawbacks to consider, particularly with high fees and variable delivery conditions.

‍

Now, let's take a closer look at the Pros and Cons of Instacart and see how it stacks up against DoorDash in terms of grocery delivery.

‍

Pros and Cons of Instacart

As you weigh the options in DoorDash vs Instacart, it's important to consider both platforms' strengths and weaknesses. Let's analyze the pros and cons of Instacart.

‍

Advantages of Instacart

Here are a few advantages of Instacart:

• Wide Grocery Selection: Instacart partners with major grocery chains, offering a broad selection of products, from fresh produce to pantry staples, all from one platform.
• Same-Day Delivery: Instacart provides fast, same-day delivery, often within hours of placing an order, making it an ideal solution for last-minute grocery needs.
• Instacart+ Membership: For frequent shoppers, Instacart+ provides free delivery on orders over a certain amount and reduces service fees, making it a cost-effective choice for regular users.
• Personalized Shopping Experience: The app learns your preferences over time, making it easy to reorder your favorite items and even suggest related products based on your shopping history.
• Multiple Store Options: Instacart allows you to shop from multiple stores within your area, making it convenient to buy everything you need without leaving the app.

‍

Drawbacks of Instacart

Doordash also has some drawbacks, these include:

• High Service Fees: Just like DoorDash, Instacart charges service fees, and these can quickly add up, especially for smaller orders or during peak demand times.
• Inconsistent Shopper Quality: The quality of your shopping experience can vary, as Instacart relies on individual shoppers to pick items. Sometimes, substitutions or missing products can be frustrating.
• Limited Delivery Zones: While Instacart is widely available in urban areas, its delivery zones can be limited in suburban or rural regions, reducing access for some customers.
• Product Availability Issues: As Instacart depends on store inventory, there's always a chance that some items you order might be out of stock or unavailable.
• Expensive for Smaller Orders: For small grocery orders, Instacart's fees and tip structure may make the service less affordable compared to in-person shopping.

Instacart shines with its broad grocery selection and personalized shopping experience, but its service fees and occasional product availability issues may be a downside for some users.

With both DoorDash and Instacart offering their unique strengths, now let's understand which one fits your needs best.

‍

Which One Should You Choose?

As a restaurant owner, deciding between DoorDash vs Instacart depends on your specific business needs and delivery goals. Both platforms bring unique features to the table, and understanding when to pick each is key to boosting your restaurant's efficiency and reaching more customers.

‍

When to Pick DoorDash?

If your restaurant specializes in food delivery and you want a fast, reliable service for meals, DoorDash is a great choice. DoorDash has a broad delivery network, excellent customer service, and a user-friendly interface. It's ideal for restaurants that focus on takeout and food delivery, and it also offers convenient subscription services like DashPass to attract loyal customers.

‍

When to Pick Instacart?

Suppose your restaurant offers grocery or meal kits. In that case, Instacart can help you reach customers who prefer grocery shopping or picking up ingredients to prepare meals at home. Instacart is especially beneficial for catering to customers who want fresh ingredients delivered quickly, making it an excellent option for restaurants offering grocery delivery or pre-packaged meal kits.

‍

Factors to Consider

Here are a few factors that you must consider before choosing your delivery partner:

• Needs: If you focus mainly on food delivery, DoorDash is the go-to. But if you offer groceries or meal kits, Instacart might be the better choice.
• Location: Check delivery zone availability. DoorDash may work better in urban areas, while Instacart's grocery-focused services may be ideal for specific regions.
• Fees: Consider the cost of service fees. Both platforms have different fee structures, which could impact your profit margins.
• Delivery Time: Look at the speed of delivery. DoorDash is known for fast food deliveries, while Instacart may take a bit longer, especially for grocery orders.
• Customer Base: Understand where your customers are. If they prefer convenience and quick meals, DoorDash might suit them better. If they value quality groceries, Instacart will be a hit.

Ultimately, the choice between DoorDash vs Instacart hinges on your restaurant's services and goals. Whether you need a food delivery platform or a grocery delivery service, both platforms bring something unique to the table.

‍

But what if you didn’t have to choose between the two?

‍

Before choosing between DoorDash and Instacart, it’s important to take a step back and look at what each platform truly provides and what they don’t. That’s where iOrders stands out, offering a restaurant-first alternative that puts you in control, reduces third-party costs, and strengthens your direct connection with customers.

Here’s a quick look at how the three platforms stack up:

‍

Comparison: Instacart vs. DoorDash vs. iOrders

Looking to enhance your restaurant's digital presence and simplify delivery? Let's see how iOrders can help you manage your operations smoothly.

‍

How iOrders Can Help Restaurants Thrive?

Choosing between DoorDash vs Instacart is just one part of running a successful restaurant. You also need the right tools to attract customers, boost delivery sales, and grow your brand. 

iOrders help restaurants create a strong digital presence and run delivery services on their terms. With smart technology and marketing support, iOrders gives restaurant owners full control without relying heavily on third-party apps.

‍

Here's how iOrders can help your restaurant succeed beyond DoorDash vs Instacart:

• Commission-Free Online Ordering: iOrders lets you accept orders directly through your website or social media pages without paying high commissions. You get full control over customer data and keep more profits from every sale.

• Website and QR Ordering: Offer a smooth ordering experience with a custom website and QR code-based menus. Diners can browse, order, and pay from their phones, making their experience faster and more convenient.

• Delivery-as-a-Service: Expand your reach with delivery options without managing your own fleet. iOrders handles the logistics, helping you offer reliable delivery while focusing on what you do best: serving great food.

• Managed Marketing Services: iOrders supports your marketing efforts with digital campaigns, social media marketing, paid ads, and emails. The service drives more orders and brings repeat business without you lifting a finger.

• Loyalty and Rewards: Encourage customers to come back with personalized loyalty programs. Offer reward points, discounts, and special promotions that keep your restaurant top of mind.

• Smart Campaigns: Use smart, data-driven marketing to target customers based on their preferences and behavior. iOrders helps you run efficient campaigns that get real results without wasting your budget.

• AI-Powered Review System: Manage your online reputation with AI tools that analyze customer feedback and automate responses. Stay engaged with your customers and turn every review into an opportunity.

• White-Label Mobile App: Launch your own branded mobile app where customers can order, earn rewards, and receive exclusive deals. Strengthen brand loyalty and make ordering easier than ever.

‍

Ready to break free from heavy commission fees and grow your delivery business? Book a free demo with iOrders today and take control of your restaurant's success!

‍

Conclusion

Choosing between DoorDash vs Instacart depends on your business needs and customer expectations. DoorDash works best for restaurant meals and quick deliveries, while Instacart focuses on grocery shopping and larger orders. Each platform brings unique advantages and challenges depending on what your customers need and where you operate.

‍

If you want to move beyond the usual Instacart vs DoorDash choice, iOrders can help. iOrders offers commission-free ordering, delivery services, marketing support, loyalty programs, and a branded mobile app, all designed to give your restaurant more control and better profits. You can deliver a smoother experience without depending on costly third-party apps.

‍

Are you ready to grow your restaurant's online sales and keep more revenue? Book a free demo with iOrders today and take your delivery strategy to the next level!