Top 10 Most Profitable Restaurant Menu Items for 2025

July 10, 2025

Table of contents

In the competitive world of restaurants, profitability isn't just about high sales; it's about smart strategy, and nowhere is this more evident than in your menu. A thoughtfully engineered menu can directly impact your bottom line, while an unoptimized one can quietly drain your potential earnings.

According to Menu Cover Depot, implementing effective menu engineering strategies can increase profitability by 10% to 15%. Beyond raising prices, it involves a scientific approach to analyzing item costs, popularity, and pricing to make informed decisions.

This guide is your blueprint to maximizing your restaurant's financial performance. We'll unveil the top 10 most profitable menu items for 2025 and provide actionable strategies to integrate them. Let's ensure your menu isn't just a list of dishes but a powerful tool for enhanced revenue and sustained success.

Why Focus on Profitable Menu Items?

Amidst rising ingredient costs and labor expenses, identifying and prioritizing high-margin dishes is more crucial than ever. Focusing on profitable menu items means you're maximizing the return on every plate you serve. It's about making deliberate, data-informed decisions that strengthen your financial results.

The key considerations for selecting profitable dishes boil down to three things: cost of ingredients, appropriate pricing that reflects value and demand, and strategies to minimize food waste. By mastering these, you can ensure your offerings appeal to customers while significantly boosting your bottom line.

Now, it's time to take a closer look at the most profitable menu items for 2025.

Also Read: Innovative Restaurant Revenue Streams to Boost Profits

Most Profitable Restaurant Menu Items for 2025

Most Profitable Restaurant Menu Items for 2025

The restaurant industry continues its robust growth, projected to hit a record $1.5 trillion in sales in the U.S. in 2025, according to the National Restaurant Association. So, strategically selecting menu items with high margins is key. These items combine high demand with efficient production and excellent pricing flexibility.

Here are the top 10 dishes that consistently deliver strong profits:

1. Burgers

Burgers remain a powerhouse of profitability. Their appeal is universal, and their core ingredients (buns, patties, basic toppings) are relatively inexpensive. This allows for significant markups, especially when you offer gourmet options.

  • Profitability Strategies: Offer premium upgrades like plant-based patties, artisanal cheeses, unique sauces, or exotic toppings (truffle aioli, caramelized onions). Create signature burgers that command higher prices. Bundle them with sides and drinks for increased average check size.

2. Pizzas

Pizzas are a profit marvel due to their low base cost and incredible versatility. Dough, sauce, and cheese are economical when bought in bulk, providing a strong foundation for high-margin sales.

  • Profitability Strategies: Encourage upsells with premium toppings (prosciutto, roasted vegetables, specialty cheeses). Offer unique crusts (gluten-free, cauliflower) or seasonal/limited-time specialty pizzas. Consider personal-sized pizzas for higher per-unit pricing.

3. Pastas

Pasta dishes are incredibly profitable due to their low ingredient cost and high perceived value. Basic pasta and sauce are cheap to purchase, but adding a protein or premium sauce significantly increases the selling price.

  • Profitability Strategies: Offer a variety of sauces (pesto, Alfredo, Bolognese) for customization. Upsell by allowing customers to add grilled chicken, shrimp, or seasonal vegetables. Adjust portion sizes for different price points (e.g., appetizer size vs. main course).

4. Coffee and Tea

Beverages, especially coffee and tea, boast some of the highest markups in the industry. The cost of raw ingredients is minimal compared to the retail price, particularly for specialty drinks.

  • Profitability Strategies: Capitalize on the artisanal coffee and specialty tea trend with unique blends, seasonal lattes, or signature iced teas. Offer add-ons like flavored syrups, alternative milks, or whipped cream. Promote combos with pastries or brunch items.

5. Fried Snacks

Items like fries, onion rings, and fried pickles are simple to make, widely popular, and have exceptionally low food costs. They are perfect for generating quick, high-margin sales as sides or appetizers.

  • Profitability Strategies: Offer unique dipping sauces at an extra charge. Create "loaded" versions (e.g., loaded fries with cheese and bacon) for a higher price point. Promote them as shareable appetizers to boost group checks.

6. Shakes and Mojitos

These indulgent drinks, whether non-alcoholic shakes or refreshing cocktails like mojitos, offer fantastic profit margins due to their high perceived value and often simple, low-cost base ingredients.

  • Profitability Strategies: Use premium ingredients (gourmet ice cream, fresh fruit) to justify higher prices. Offer unique flavor combinations or "adult" versions with spirits. Promote them as dessert alternatives or premium drink options.

7. Toasts and Brunch Items

Brunch has exploded in popularity, and items like avocado toast, egg dishes, and specialty pancakes or waffles offer excellent profitability. They often use common, affordable ingredients but have a high perceived value.

  • Profitability Strategies: Offer premium toppings (poached eggs, smoked salmon, artisan jams). Encourage customization with add-on proteins or extra sides. Create visually appealing presentations for social media buzz.

8. Soups and Stews

Soups and stews are budget-friendly powerhouses. They can effectively utilize seasonal or leftover ingredients, significantly reducing food waste and costs. They offer comfort and can be priced affordably yet yield high margins.

  • Profitability Strategies: Offer a daily rotating "soup of the day" to create excitement. Pair them with a side of bread or a half-sandwich for an upsell. Highlight seasonal ingredients to attract health-conscious customers.

9. Protein-Rich Salads

Salads have evolved from simple sides to profitable main courses, driven by the demand for healthy, customizable meals. Adding protein elevates their value and price point.

  • Profitability Strategies: Offer a variety of protein add-ons (grilled chicken, steak, tofu, salmon). Provide unique dressings or premium toppings for an extra charge. Market them as wholesome, customizable meal solutions.

10. Grilled Seafood

Grilled seafood dishes like lobster tails, shrimp skewers, and fish fillets have a high perceived value in the minds of diners, allowing for significant markups despite sometimes higher ingredient costs. Their healthy appeal also attracts a strong customer base.

  • Profitability Strategies: Include them in combo platters with low-cost, high-margin sides like grilled seasonal vegetables or rice, increasing the check and enhancing the experience. Promote grilled seafood as a healthy yet indulgent option to attract health-conscious diners willing to pay more. Focus on sustainable sourcing to appeal to conscious consumers.

Implementing these practices consistently allows your restaurant to stay competitive and adapt to changing customer preferences.

Now, let's understand how menu engineering helps you sell more of these items.

Also Read: Restaurant Marketing Strategies and Ideas for 2025

Mastering Menu Engineering for Maximum Profitability

Mastering Menu Engineering for Maximum Profitability

Knowing which items are profitable is just one part of the equation; how you present and manage them is equally vital. Menu engineering is the art and science of analyzing and optimizing your menu to boost profitability systematically. It's about making data-informed decisions based on each dish's performance, from cost to popularity.

Here's how to apply these principles:

1. Calculate Plate Costs Accurately

The foundation of menu engineering is knowing the exact cost of every dish, including ingredients, preparation, and even a portion of labor. This helps you understand its true profitability. Without this, you're just guessing.

2. Categorize Your Menu Items

Classify each dish into one of four categories based on its popularity and profitability:

  • Stars: High popularity, high profitability. These are your champions. Promote them heavily and ensure consistent quality.
  • Puzzles: Low popularity, high profitability. These have potential. Work on boosting their visibility, improving descriptions, or refining presentation to increase demand.
  • Workhorses: High popularity, low profitability. These are consistent sellers but don't bring in much money. Consider slight price increases or finding ways to reduce production costs without compromising quality.
  • Dogs: Low popularity, low profitability. These are likely draining resources. It's often best to remove them to free up space and focus on more profitable options.

3. Strategic Menu Design Principles

Your menu's physical design can subtly guide customers toward profitable choices:

  • Strategic Placement: Research shows that items placed in prime areas (like the "sweet spot" in the top right or center of a menu) receive the most attention. Utilize this space for your "Stars" and "Puzzles."
  • Psychology of Pricing: Price items just below whole numbers (e.g., $9.95 instead of $10) to create a perception of better value.
  • Descriptive Language: Use vivid, mouth-watering language to entice customers. Instead of "Meatloaf," try "Homestyle Meatloaf with Savory Gravy and Creamy Mashed Potatoes."
  • Font Variations and Visual Cues: Use bold fonts, boxes, or distinctive sections to highlight high-profit dishes and draw the eye.

4. Train Your Staff for Upselling

An informed and enthusiastic staff can significantly impact your bottom line. Train your team on the profitability of each item, the best upsell opportunities (e.g., suggesting a premium topping for a pizza, or a specialty drink with a burger), and descriptive language to enhance their recommendations.

5. Test and Adjust Continuously

Menu optimization isn't a one-time task; it's an ongoing process. Regularly test different configurations, promotions, and pricing strategies. Continually analyze performance data and gather customer feedback to make informed adjustments.

Now that you've grasped the fundamentals of menu engineering, let's look into creative concepts that not only boost revenue but also captivate your customers and keep them coming back for more.

Also Read: Restaurant SOPs: Implementation Guide and Free Templates

Innovative Menu Ideas to Boost Restaurant Revenue

Innovative Menu Ideas to Boost Restaurant Revenue

In a highly competitive dining industry, restaurants need to keep innovating to attract customers and boost profits. Here are five creative menu strategies, with real-world examples, to inspire your restaurant's next step.

1. Cheese Boards

Cheese boards have become a popular menu item, offering a shareable and customizable choice that appeals to a broad range of customers. They deliver high-profit margins because of their low food costs and versatility.

Restaurants can feature various cheeses, meats, fruits, and accompaniments to craft a unique dining experience. 

Example: The Church Brewing Co. offers a selection of signature sauces that can complement cheese boards, enhancing the overall dining experience.

2. Seasonal Offerings

Seasonal menus allow restaurants to capitalize on fresh, in-season ingredients, reducing costs and increasing flavor profiles. By rotating dishes based on the time of year, restaurants can keep their offerings exciting and aligned with customer expectations. 

Example: Favorite Neighbor, a European-inspired restaurant in New Braunfels, Texas, plans to offer scratch-made tapas and sandwiches on house-baked bread, featuring seasonal ingredients to create a cozy, neighborhood-style ambiance.

3. Signature Sauces and Dips

Developing unique sauces and dips can set a restaurant apart from competitors and encourage repeat business. Signature sauces add a personal touch and can be marketed as a special feature of the menu. 

Example: Schlotzsky's is known for its distinctive signature sauce, which has become a defining element of their brand.

4. Chicken Wings

Chicken wings remain a popular and profitable menu item due to their versatility and high demand. Offering a variety of flavors and preparations can attract a broad customer base. Restaurants can experiment with different sauces, cooking methods, and presentations to create unique wing offerings. 

Example: Panago Pizza launched the Hot Honey Brooklyn Pepperoni Pizza, featuring layers of pepperoni, mozzarella, and cheddar, topped with a hot honey drizzle, showcasing the popularity of bold flavors in menu items.

5. Unique Menu Items

Introducing unique and creative menu items can generate buzz and attract customers seeking new dining experiences. These items can range from innovative takes on classic dishes to entirely new creations. 

Example: Side A, a new San Francisco restaurant, offers inventive dishes like Italian beef short rib gnocchi and a lavish chicken cutlet bathed in honey mustard, embracing a maximalist culinary style that combines bold, whimsical flavor fusions with refined technique. 

Implementing these innovative menu ideas can significantly enhance your restaurant's appeal and profitability. However, to maximize the impact of these offerings, it's essential to utilize technology effectively. 

Next, let's understand how iOrders can assist in optimizing your menu engineering efforts.

Also Read: Expert Insights on Food Trends 2025

How iOrders Can Power Your Menu Engineering?

How iOrders Can Power Your Menu Engineering?

Menu engineering is crucial, but implementing these strategies can be challenging without the right tools. iOrders offers a range of features that streamline the process of menu optimization and boost restaurant revenue, allowing you to manage your menus, analyze sales data, implement marketing strategies, and much more, all from a single platform.

Here's how iOrders can supercharge your menu engineering efforts:

1. Menu Updates (Real-Time Update Across Platforms)

One of the main challenges for restaurants is maintaining the consistency of their menu across different platforms, from in-house menus to online ordering systems and delivery apps. 

iOrders enables real-time menu updates, instantly reflecting changes like new dishes, prices, or seasonal items. It prevents confusion, reduces errors, and ensures customers see the latest offerings.

2. Analyzing Menu (Get Data from All Sources)

Understanding which menu items perform well and which don't is essential for making informed decisions. iOrders integrates with your POS system and gathers valuable data on sales, customer preferences, and purchasing patterns from sources like the website, online ordering system, and white-label mobile app

With this data, you can analyze your menu's performance, identify top-selling items, and pinpoint dishes that may need adjustments or removal. By using data-driven insights, restaurants can optimize their menu for maximum profitability.

3. Smart Campaigns (Marketing)

iOrders offers powerful marketing tools that help you promote high-margin, underperforming, or seasonal menu items. With smart campaigns, you can create personalized promotions that target specific customer segments based on their preferences or purchase history. 

Whether it's sending out an email blast about a new dish or running a special promotion for a limited-time menu item, iOrders enables you to engage with your customers in a meaningful way, encouraging them to try profitable dishes and increasing sales.

4. Customized Loyalty Programs (Retention)

Retaining customers is just as important as attracting new ones. iOrders' customized loyalty programs allow restaurants to create tailored rewards that encourage repeat visits. 

By offering loyalty points or rewards for high-margin items, restaurants can boost sales and customer loyalty. Loyalty programs also gather customer data to customize marketing and menu options.

5. AI-powered Review System (Menu Adjustments)

Customer feedback is invaluable for improving your menu, but manually sifting through reviews can be time-consuming. iOrders' AI-powered review system helps automate the process by generating personalized responses to customer reviews and feedback. 

This system analyzes customer comments' sentiment and offers insights. It helps you understand preferences, whether customers love your seasonal soup or have dish suggestions, so that you can adjust your menu.

Conclusion

Menu engineering isn't just about listing dishes; it's about strategically designing your menu to boost profitability. Analyzing costs, pricing, and preferences helps develop a menu that maximizes revenue, reduces waste, and encourages repeat visits. A data-driven, right menu can significantly impact your restaurant's success.

With iOrders, simplifying the menu engineering process has never been easier. From real-time updates and data analysis to smart marketing campaigns and AI-powered reviews, it equips you with all the tools you need to optimize your menu and boost profitability effortlessly.

Ready to take your restaurant's profitability to the next level? Contact iOrders today and discover how our platform can help streamline your menu engineering and drive success.

Related Blogs

Book a free demo

By providing a telephone number and submitting this form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging. Reply Help for more information
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.